iCarly Wiki


DEBATE: Does Carly deserve Freddie?

~This is NOT an Anti-Creddie Blog; anyone, regardless of where they stand, is welcome to join in on the discussion, and express their opinion.~

I personally don't think so. Carly has had countless chances to be with Freddie, and when she doesn't completely reject him, it is for selfish reasons. Example #1: It seems to me that Carly only danced with Freddie in iSpeed Date because her real date didn't work out. And if you remember, she previously rejected him in that very same episode. Example #2: When Freddie saved Carly's life, Carly all of a sudden saw him in a whole new light, when she previously wanted nothing to do with him romantically. To me, this is rather suspicious. One could argue that Carly simply wanted to protect the friendship but saving her life was just the "icing on the cake"* to get her to like him. As you can see, this is a topic that is open for debate, and I am really curious to hear both sides. There is no doubt in my mind that Freddie deserves Carly (although that could be open for discussion, as well.), and Carly and Freddie definetely deserve each other as friends. However, this is just my opinion.

I want to know what you guys think. Where do you guys stand on the matter? Do you believe Carly is an honest, wholesome person, who just wants to protect her friendship with Freddie because it's important to her, or do you think Carly is acting selfish and needs to get an attitude check? Discuss away!!!!!!

  • Quoted from Giantapplepie.

Also on Fandom

Random Wiki